- About the League
Where We Stand
Donate
Join Us
Pay Dues
Contact Us
Visit us on Facebook and become a Fan!
Quick Links for CitizensVoting & Elections
Register to vote
Find Your Polling Place
Restore your voting rights
"About the Help America Vote Act" (pdf)
Vote411.org
Read more
State Legislature & Congress
Who Speaks for You?
Find State Legislation & Take Action
The AL Legislature: Facts & Issues
Courts
"The Courts and Judicial Selection in AL" (pdf)
Environment
Environmental Management in AL: Facts & Issues
The State of Climate Change (LWVUS)
The Alabama Constitution
Resources on Constitutional Reform in AL
Initiative
LWVAL Action Priority Level III - If and when opportunities arise, assess if action is feasible given resources and priorities.Click a bill to see sponsor(s), summary (including link to full text), League action and justification for that action, and progress of the bill through the legislative progress. Inclusion of a bill in this list does not necessarily indicate LWVAL support. The League's position, if any, is noted under League Action & Justification.
Indicates change from previous week's report such as new progress in the legislature and/or League action. These updates are in green font.LWVAL is monitoring these bills.
SB 81 & HB 201 - Initiative, constitutional amendments, proposed by people, authorized, Legislature may offer alternate proposal, const. amend.
Sponsor(s):
SB 81 - Sen. Paul Sanford
HB 201- Rep. Mike Ball, Rep. Mac McCutcheon, Rep. Greg Canfield, Rep. Mike Hill, Rep. Randy Wood, Rep. Blaine Galliher
Summary/Synopsis: These identical bills would propose a constitutional amendment to provide that the people also may propose the enactment of general laws and constitutional amendments by an initiative measure subject to the same limitations imposed on the Legislature and that the Legislature may offer an alternate proposal.(companion bills)
League Action and Justification: LWVAL is monitoring SB 81 and HB 201. These bills include points in the League position such as distribution of signatures across the state in preliminary petition and more signatures for constitutional amendments than statutory law. They use the Alabama Law Center, Legislative Reference Service, and Legislative Fiscal Office. They provide an opportunity for the Legislature to offer alternative versions of the proposed law with both versions offered to the voters.
The bills omit, however, all safeguards League favors to prevent abuses by signature gatherers, who are more often hired firms rather than grassroots activists, especially if the initiative is part of a group’s attempt to build national support for their agenda. Such abuses have been well-documented both in gathering signatures for the petition and in the campaign for the public vote. LWVAL recommends full disclosure of all supporting organizations, and disclosure of the sources of contributions and amounts spent on campaign advertisements.
Both bills specify that no law adopted by initiative under this section shall be repealed or amended except by vote of the people, unless the bills provides otherwise. Such a provision has created difficulties in states where initiatives are many, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures and comments on California’s circumstances.
During the study of Initiative &Referendum, both LWVAL and Local Leagues approved support for Initiative with reservations. League favors initiative only with safeguards against demonstrated abuses.
Before a decision to support or oppose, more study is needed, such as comparison of the effects of the two different processes, and weighting of the consequences of omission of LWVAL recommendations. In particular LWV must consider how well the bills meet the criteria added to LWVAL’s Constitutional Reform positions:
“If the Alabama Constitution authorizes initiative and referendum, the Constitution should either contain safeguards in the initiative and referendum process to protect representative and deliberative democracy, guarantee basic rights found in the U.S. and Alabama Constitutions, maintain essential state services, and reduce the influence of special interests or require that he legislature include such safeguards in any enabling or other initiative and referendum legislation.”
Bill Progress in Legislature:
SB 81 - 1st Read: 1/12/10 and assigned to
HB 201 - 1st Read: 1/12/10 and assigned to
SB 81 - Sen. Paul Sanford
HB 201- Rep. Mike Ball, Rep. Mac McCutcheon, Rep. Greg Canfield, Rep. Mike Hill, Rep. Randy Wood, Rep. Blaine Galliher
Summary/Synopsis: These identical bills would propose a constitutional amendment to provide that the people also may propose the enactment of general laws and constitutional amendments by an initiative measure subject to the same limitations imposed on the Legislature and that the Legislature may offer an alternate proposal.(companion bills)
League Action and Justification: LWVAL is monitoring SB 81 and HB 201. These bills include points in the League position such as distribution of signatures across the state in preliminary petition and more signatures for constitutional amendments than statutory law. They use the Alabama Law Center, Legislative Reference Service, and Legislative Fiscal Office. They provide an opportunity for the Legislature to offer alternative versions of the proposed law with both versions offered to the voters.
The bills omit, however, all safeguards League favors to prevent abuses by signature gatherers, who are more often hired firms rather than grassroots activists, especially if the initiative is part of a group’s attempt to build national support for their agenda. Such abuses have been well-documented both in gathering signatures for the petition and in the campaign for the public vote. LWVAL recommends full disclosure of all supporting organizations, and disclosure of the sources of contributions and amounts spent on campaign advertisements.
Both bills specify that no law adopted by initiative under this section shall be repealed or amended except by vote of the people, unless the bills provides otherwise. Such a provision has created difficulties in states where initiatives are many, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures and comments on California’s circumstances.
During the study of Initiative &Referendum, both LWVAL and Local Leagues approved support for Initiative with reservations. League favors initiative only with safeguards against demonstrated abuses.
Before a decision to support or oppose, more study is needed, such as comparison of the effects of the two different processes, and weighting of the consequences of omission of LWVAL recommendations. In particular LWV must consider how well the bills meet the criteria added to LWVAL’s Constitutional Reform positions:
“If the Alabama Constitution authorizes initiative and referendum, the Constitution should either contain safeguards in the initiative and referendum process to protect representative and deliberative democracy, guarantee basic rights found in the U.S. and Alabama Constitutions, maintain essential state services, and reduce the influence of special interests or require that he legislature include such safeguards in any enabling or other initiative and referendum legislation.”
Bill Progress in Legislature:
SB 81 - 1st Read: 1/12/10 and assigned to
HB 201 - 1st Read: 1/12/10 and assigned to
SB 275 - Initiative, constitutional amendments, proposed by people, authorized, Legislature may offer alternate proposal, const. amend.
Sponsor(s): Sen. T. D. "Ted" Little
Summary/Synopsis: Constitutional Amendment: This bill would propose an amendment to the Constitution of Alabama of 1901 to provide that the people also may propose the enactment of general laws and constitutional amendments by an initiative measure subject to the same limitations imposed on the Legislature and that the Legislature may offer an alternate proposal.
League Action and Justification: LWVAL is monitoring SB 275.
Bill Progress in Legislature: 1st Read: 1/19/10 and assigned to
Summary/Synopsis: Constitutional Amendment: This bill would propose an amendment to the Constitution of Alabama of 1901 to provide that the people also may propose the enactment of general laws and constitutional amendments by an initiative measure subject to the same limitations imposed on the Legislature and that the Legislature may offer an alternate proposal.
League Action and Justification: LWVAL is monitoring SB 275.
Bill Progress in Legislature: 1st Read: 1/19/10 and assigned to
More issues